I know NYS is broke, but this is getting ridiculous

  

About two years before my wife Jeanne passed away she started a photography business. It was more of a hobby really, a great way to express her creative side and pay for the expensive toys that accompany such a pasttime. She did everything by the book. She created a business plan, filed a dba, got a loan and filed all the appropriate forms with the NYS state taxation department. They’re great at collecting taxes. If you’re a day late with “their” (our) money, there will be a form letter waiting in your mailbox asking for prompt payment. With such a well oiled machine, I’m really at a loss as to why they can’t seem to correct my situation.

      Jeanne passed away in August. She was very ill for the previous year, to the point where she couldn’t work. Admittedly, no paperwork was filed for the first two quarters of 2007. There were no jobs done, no money collected. In the fall of last year I received a letter from NYS saying since they didn’t receive any paperwork about Jeanne’s business, they would estimate how much taxes the photography business could have owed. I called them, sent in a copy of her death certificate, and was told NO PROBLEM…we’ll take care of it from here. You don’t owe NYS anything. That was easy I thought. Yeah. Too easy. The story goes on and on.

     In March, I received another letter saying the company owed taxes. AGAIN, I called the NYS taxation department and AGAIN told them the story of what happened and AGAIN faxed in all the forms I needed to in order to prove there were no taxes owed. NO PROBLEM….we’ll take care of it from here. You don’t owe NYS anything.         

      Zoom ahead a month, I have my taxes done and find out I’m getting a $500 refund from NYS. Cool! Well, not really. NYS TOOK MY MONEY and said it was for taxes owed on my wifes business. Yes, the business that had done nothing for close to a year and generated zero income. They had been told that through all the proper channels twice. The business that I was told is all set, we don’t owe them anything. I made my third call to the NYS taxation department almost two weeks ago. Faxed the forms, explained the situation. NO PROBLEM…we’ll take care of it from here. You don’t owe NYS anything.  

       Today, waiting in my mailbox….wait for it…yes, another form telling me the business (which no longer exists, and had the dba closed out to stop all this nonsense) owes back taxes for the latest quarter. Are you guys kidding me? The last time I called, just for the heck of it, I asked if there were any notations on the tax id number explaining the situation. “No, I don’t see any sir” I was told. Translation: 2 idiot state employees didn’t bother to note the situation on the business account. The third person I spoke with told me everything would be taken care of but low and behold it wasn’t. Look closely, this is my shocked face. I’m sorry about the idiot comment. I shouldn’t have said that. I should actually have said 3 idiot state employees, because the last one I talked to obviously didn’t do her job correctly either. They now have three copies of my wifes death certificate. Not only is this painful on a personal level to deal with, but it’s also painful to know these three people who will draw a state pension when they leave their cushy civil service state jobs are so inept at their jobs that I will now have to deal with this for a fourth time.

      ATTENTION NYS TAXATION DEPARTMENT: I’M DONE. YOU WIN. COME GET YOUR MONEY. I’M ON THE AIR EVERY WEEKDAY FROM 3-7. I’LL GLADLY WRITE YOU A CHECK FOR THE BACK TAXES I DON’T OWE AS I TELL EVERYONE LISTENING WHAT AN INCREDIBLY WONDERFUL JOB YOU PEOPLE ARE DOING FOR THE CITIZENS OF NEW YORK. My secret fantasy is that somehow a link to this story will get forwarded to a state legislator and they will come galloping to my rescue. My knight in shining armor to keep the evil tax man at bay. Ok, actually, I’m just hoping my FOURTH attempt to call these people will result in somebody actually doing their job correctly. I’ll settle for that. I’ve become complacent and expectant of crappy service when I walk into a store or fast food restaurant where they pay people minimum wage. I don’t expect that kind of service from people pulling down 50 G a year. What a waste of our taxe dollars. Schools don’t have books. The city is laying off firemen to balance the budget. Yet inept and incompetent civil servents are left in place collecting a paycheck for a job done horribly.  

3 Responses to “I know NYS is broke, but this is getting ridiculous”

  1. Nikki Morrill Says:

    That is truly awful…and got me really fired up. It isn’t just the state…my mom kept getting a bill from the Town of Greece for a $6.00 dog license after she had contacted them 3 different times and the dog had been gone for 2 years. I know it isn’t the same, but it just goes to show that when an organization has so many working parts…they work fine independently but none of them work well together.
    Anyways…I think I might have a solution to your problem. What bank was the DBA at, and did she pay her quarterly taxes at the bank or directly to the govt at the end of the year? I would try to have the bank contact them and prove that she was current up until the point where she claimed $0 income- which meant she owed nothing, and then when and why it was closed. Sometimes govt offices take the bank’s word more seriously than an individual. They have this underlying belief that everyone is trying to scam their way out of paying taxes…and unfortunately the few that truly aren’t trying to get away with something suffer!

  2. Alyson Says:

    I’m not sure if you’ll still check this since it’s been a few days but I thought I’d make a suggestion. I know people think CPAs and other accountants are ridiculously expensive, but sometimes it takes one to get your tax problems solved. I am a new CPA and have noticed that when a client tries to solve a tax problem by themself it causes much aggravation. All who eventually come for help seem to feel much better in the end. I’m not touting my services, but it may be worth looking for some professional help in this case. Good luck!!

  3. jeff jesionowski Says:

    First off, I am sry for the loss of your wife and the troubles that you are having with the taxes. In the “great” state of New York you can’t count on anyone to get the tax collections dept. or really any dept. to help you unless it’s in their favor. I had a check due to me for a “mistake” the state made with reguards to 2006 return and it wasn’t ’till June of ‘07 that I finally recieved my check. I had to laugh becuase if I had owed them money and didn’t pay for that amount of time i’m sure they would have found it their duty to fine me and it makes me wonder-Why can’t we fine them for the same things they can fine us for? Take care and God bless!

Leave a Reply